IM Player Assessment Sheet
Track player progress, contributions, and development during sessions
Session Information
Date: _________________ Session #: _____ Malmon: _________________________
Scenario: _____________________________________ Duration: ________
Total Players: _____ New Players: _____ Returning Players: _____
Team Composition
| Role | Player Name | Experience Level | Session Goals |
|---|---|---|---|
| Detective | ☐ New ☐ Some ☐ Experienced | ||
| Protector | ☐ New ☐ Some ☐ Experienced | ||
| Tracker | ☐ New ☐ Some ☐ Experienced | ||
| Communicator | ☐ New ☐ Some ☐ Experienced | ||
| Crisis Manager | ☐ New ☐ Some ☐ Experienced | ||
| Threat Hunter | ☐ New ☐ Some ☐ Experienced |
Individual Player Assessment
Player 1: _________________________ Role: _________________
Participation Quality
- Engagement Level: ☐ Passive ☐ Moderate ☐ Active ☐ Highly Engaged
- Question Asking: ☐ None ☐ Few ☐ Regular ☐ Frequent
- Contribution Frequency: ☐ Rare ☐ Occasional ☐ Regular ☐ Frequent
Role Performance
- Role Understanding: ☐ Learning ☐ Basic ☐ Good ☐ Excellent
- Role-Specific Skills: ☐ Developing ☐ Adequate ☐ Strong ☐ Advanced
- Role Archetype Embrace: ☐ Minimal ☐ Some ☐ Good ☐ Excellent
Key Contributions This Session
Growth Areas Observed
XP Earned This Session
- Participation: _____ XP
- Key Discovery: _____ XP
- Successful Containment: _____ XP
- Exceptional Teamwork: _____ XP
- Learning Achievement: _____ XP
- Total: _____ XP
Badge Progress
- Network Security: ________________
- Endpoint Protection: ________________
- Data Security: ________________
- Incident Response: ________________
- Threat Intelligence: ________________
- Communication & Leadership: ________________
Player 2: _________________________ Role: _________________
Participation Quality
- Engagement Level: ☐ Passive ☐ Moderate ☐ Active ☐ Highly Engaged
- Question Asking: ☐ None ☐ Few ☐ Regular ☐ Frequent
- Contribution Frequency: ☐ Rare ☐ Occasional ☐ Regular ☐ Frequent
Role Performance
- Role Understanding: ☐ Learning ☐ Basic ☐ Good ☐ Excellent
- Role-Specific Skills: ☐ Developing ☐ Adequate ☐ Strong ☐ Advanced
- Role Archetype Embrace: ☐ Minimal ☐ Some ☐ Good ☐ Excellent
Key Contributions This Session
Growth Areas Observed
XP Earned This Session
- Participation: _____ XP
- Key Discovery: _____ XP
- Successful Containment: _____ XP
- Exceptional Teamwork: _____ XP
- Learning Achievement: _____ XP
- Total: _____ XP
Badge Progress
- Network Security: ________________
- Endpoint Protection: ________________
- Data Security: ________________
- Incident Response: ________________
- Threat Intelligence: ________________
- Communication & Leadership: ________________
Player 3: _________________________ Role: _________________
Participation Quality
- Engagement Level: ☐ Passive ☐ Moderate ☐ Active ☐ Highly Engaged
- Question Asking: ☐ None ☐ Few ☐ Regular ☐ Frequent
- Contribution Frequency: ☐ Rare ☐ Occasional ☐ Regular ☐ Frequent
Role Performance
- Role Understanding: ☐ Learning ☐ Basic ☐ Good ☐ Excellent
- Role-Specific Skills: ☐ Developing ☐ Adequate ☐ Strong ☐ Advanced
- Role Archetype Embrace: ☐ Minimal ☐ Some ☐ Good ☐ Excellent
Key Contributions This Session
Growth Areas Observed
XP Earned This Session
- Participation: _____ XP
- Key Discovery: _____ XP
- Successful Containment: _____ XP
- Exceptional Teamwork: _____ XP
- Learning Achievement: _____ XP
- Total: _____ XP
Badge Progress
- Network Security: ________________
- Endpoint Protection: ________________
- Data Security: ________________
- Incident Response: ________________
- Threat Intelligence: ________________
- Communication & Leadership: ________________
Team Dynamics Assessment
Collaboration Quality
- Role Synergy: ☐ Poor ☐ Fair ☐ Good ☐ Excellent
- Information Sharing: ☐ Limited ☐ Adequate ☐ Good ☐ Excellent
- Decision Making: ☐ Struggle ☐ Slow ☐ Steady ☐ Efficient
- Conflict Resolution: ☐ Avoided ☐ Difficult ☐ Managed ☐ Excellent
Communication Patterns
Most Vocal Players: ____________________________
Quieter Players: ________________________________
Effective Facilitators: ____________________________
Role Distribution Effectiveness
Strongest Role Performance: ______________________
Roles Needing Support: ___________________________
Missing Role Functions: ___________________________
Session Outcomes
Learning Objectives Met
- Technical Skills: ☐ Not Met ☐ Partially ☐ Mostly ☐ Fully
- Collaboration: ☐ Not Met ☐ Partially ☐ Mostly ☐ Fully
- Role Development: ☐ Not Met ☐ Partially ☐ Mostly ☐ Fully
- Cybersecurity Knowledge: ☐ Not Met ☐ Partially ☐ Mostly ☐ Fully
Malmon Encounter Success
- Initial Discovery: ☐ Missed ☐ Delayed ☐ Timely ☐ Proactive
- Investigation Depth: ☐ Surface ☐ Basic ☐ Thorough ☐ Comprehensive
- Containment Effectiveness: ☐ Failed ☐ Partial ☐ Successful ☐ Excellent
- Learning from Incident: ☐ Minimal ☐ Some ☐ Good ☐ Significant
Engagement Highlights
Most Engaged Moment: ____________________________
Best Collaborative Decision: _______________________
Breakthrough Learning Moment: ____________________
Funniest/Most Memorable Moment: ___________________
Development Recommendations
Individual Player Development
Player 1: ___________________________________
Player 2: ___________________________________
Player 3: ___________________________________
Team Development Areas
Next Session Considerations
Scenario Difficulty: ☐ Increase ☐ Maintain ☐ Decrease
Focus Areas: - [ ] Technical skills development - [ ] Role specialization - [ ] Team coordination - [ ] Communication improvement - [ ] Advanced threat scenarios
Recommended Malmon Types: ________________________
IM Reflection
What Worked Well
Facilitation Challenges
Adjustments Made During Session
Preparation Improvements for Next Time
Player Feedback Received
Follow-Up Actions
Player Communications
Session Documentation
Community Contributions
Use additional sheets for larger groups or keep digital records for easier tracking